- Hampton Bay 6 ft. H x 16 ft. W Natural Reed Fencing Mat: $26
- Backyard X-Scapes 6 ft x 16 ft Reed Fencing Mat: $28.25
- 4 Pack Backyard X-Scapes 6 ft x 16 ft Reed Fencing Mat: $110.77 ($27.69/mat)
In 2017, the CRC published this guide with several fencing mat options that work for as kosher schach that can be bought at Home Depot at a fraction of the price of traditional schach mats. That list included the mats above, as long as you place the mats perpendicular to the support beams. Be sure to read their guide for instructions and further information.
Last year the CRC posted an update saying that they are no longer offering specific recommendations as the mats might not provide more shade than sun if a few of the reeds break. But they say you can still use the previously reccomended mats as long as you add a 2nd layer of fencing mats or add on some other schach on top to make sure that you’ll have more shade than sun in your sukkah. Even with 2 layers, it will still be a fraction of the price of traditional schach mats. You can also place mats so that they overlap halfway over each other.
As always, ask your LOR for guidance.
You can your Ink Business Cash® Credit Card card to order Home Depot gift cards from Staples and get 5 points per dollar spent.
What kind of schach do you use?
Leave a Reply
23 Comments On "Save On Schach This Year From Home Depot: 6’x 16′ Reed Fencing From $26/Mat And CRC Schach Guidelines"
All opinions expressed below are user generated and the opinions aren’t provided, reviewed or endorsed by any advertiser or DansDeals.
I would highly recommend using double or triple. We used this last Sukkot and one layer barely provided any shade… YMMV
As the CRC says, you should layer 2.
With 2 you’ll have more shade than sun, even if a couple reeds break.
Is it fine that its bound with metal?
Read the CRC guide linked to in the post?
As long as you place the mats perpendicular to the support beams and have more shade than sun they are acceptable.
If I remember correctly wasn’t there a letter from I think Rabbi Twersky not to use these.
The CRC tweeted 9/13 not to purchase fencing for schach anymore, but the ones you have can be used:
“In short, cRc no longer recommends fencing material (e.g. from Home Depot) for #schach as we have found a reasonable chance this may result in not kosher schach. We suggest traditional schach material, e.g. bamboo poles, tree branches, mats specifically certified for sukkah-use.”
“#schach fencing mats bought previously when approved may be used, but make sure shade exceeds sunlight – i.e. add more schach (e.g. more layers of these mats, bamboo poles, or tree branches) to ensure halachic requirement is met of “more shade than sunlight.””
Thanks for the heads up, but that is a confusing tweet based on their published guidance that the issue is whether there is more shade than sun, which is easily resolved with having 2 layers of mats.
I’ve tweeted back for clarification:
https://twitter.com/DansDeals/status/1174403130810933248
and their reply
The bigger issue is that if the reeds break, they end up being held by the wire and not the supporting beams.
https://twitter.com/cRcKosher/status/1174413800730181632
So why in the world are previously bought mats ok??!!
Thank you so much, I just ordered one!
Bought a few last year. Very light and flimsy, so make sure to put some greenery or a 2×4 on top to prevent flyaways. Also keep in mind that 6′ width is shorter than traditional mats. Won’t last as long as the bamboo mats, but probably still worth it
Hi Dan,
Can you post any deals you find for Schach with a Hechsher?
Thank you
The cRc has a new policy this year – posted on their Facebook page and Twitter Feed – Prior to last year, the cRc had recommended certain readily available fencing material (commonly sold in Home Depot) to be used for schach and provided detailed instructions on how to place them on the sukkah. However, based on feedback from consumers on the sturdiness of those materials and how they were being used, we have determined that there is a reasonable chance that some people will end up not having kosher schach (since the fencing material could become invalidated if a few of the reeds break), unless they place multiple layers of fencing on top of their sukkah.
Accordingly, we are no longer issuing specific recommendations of fencing material, and suggest that consumers use traditional schach material such as bamboo poles, tree branches or mats specifically certified for sukkah-use. Those who have purchased approved fencing mats in previous years may continue using them, but should be vigilant to make sure that the amount of shade exceeds the amount of sunlight by adding additional schach (e.g. added layers of these mats, bamboo poles, evergreen or other tree branches) to ensure the fulfillment of the halachic requirement of “more shade than sunlight.” Also, any fencing mats should be placed perpendicular to the schach support beams in order to avoid ma’amid issues, as we have explained in previous years.
What about instructional and parts listing to build a sukkah at a fraction of cost with same ease of assembly and storage as the typical Sukka that’s are sold
don’t know how crc gave a heter to use the fencing. forget about it being filmsy.
its not made lshem schach . its made for fencing thereby its a keli that’s mekabel tuma.
also mentioned before it has metal holding the reeds together. metal is mekabel tuma.
Did you read this?
https://i.dansdeals.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/12132523/Schach2017-3.pdf
I folded it on half and threw some fresh bamboo on it with leaves. Worked out great last year
The cheapest and most kosher ones are these mats. You can find them for about $150 for 50 feet or so. There are no threads or metal. They tend to crack after few years of use. You might be able to find them in the local basket and bamboo store.
https://www.etsy.com/listing/223777259/woven-lauhala-mat-for-tall-headpieces?gpla=1&gao=1&&utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=shopping_us_a-craft_supplies_and_tools-other&utm_custom1=_kenshoo_clickid_&utm_content=go_270947675_21143440475_69017032355_pla-106551294035_m__223777259&gclid=CjwKCAjw8ZHsBRA6EiwA7hw_saj9oNkdgXdKCyIkDdbsERS9D7HzaMnmi9ueYQN8_u6QtWe85CggqhoC1v4QAvD_BwE
How is this kosher? There’s no way you can see stars. It’s very very tight
That’s definitely kosher and Rabbi Gershon Bess uses them. They have the best shade and you don’t need to see stars. The maximum thickness is when no water can leak anymore through the schach.
Why does perpendicular to support beams matter so much in this case?
So they are supported by your wood beams and not by the metal threads.
this still kosher?